Why Hire a Private Criminal Defense Attorney Instead of Relying on a Public Defender?
When you’re facing criminal charges in Cole County or anywhere in Central Missouri, one of the first questions you may ask yourself is: Should I hire a private criminal defense attorney, or rely on a public defender?
This is an important decision. Both public defenders and private attorneys are licensed, trained, and capable criminal defense lawyers. In fact, many public defenders are among the most skilled trial lawyers in the courtroom. They handle complex cases every day, and I have tremendous respect for their work.
But when it comes to protecting your future, there are key differences between having a public defender appointed to your case and choosing your own private attorney.
Public Defenders: Skilled but Overloaded
Public defenders in Missouri are hardworking, knowledgeable attorneys. Many are passionate about protecting constitutional rights and have experience that rivals private lawyers. If I were in serious trouble, there are several public defenders I would be honored to have represent me.
The challenge isn’t their skill—it’s their workload. Public defenders carry extremely heavy caseloads. That means they may not always have the time to give your case the individualized attention you want and deserve.
Private Attorneys: Choosing Your Own Champion
When you hire a private criminal defense lawyer, you’re not assigned someone at random—you select your champion. This market-based relationship puts the client in control.
You choose the attorney you believe will fight hardest for you.
You receive personalized attention. A private lawyer has the flexibility to devote more time to investigating, negotiating, and preparing your defense.
Your satisfaction matters. Private attorneys build their reputation and business on client service. If they don’t deliver, clients look elsewhere. That accountability ensures they are motivated not only to defend you, but also to keep you informed and supported throughout the process.
Unlike public defenders, who will always have a steady stream of cases regardless of client satisfaction, private attorneys must earn trust case by case.
The Bottom Line
Both public defenders and private attorneys can provide strong legal defense. But hiring a private attorney gives you something the public system can’t: the ability to choose your advocate and hold them accountable.
When your freedom and future are at stake, you deserve a lawyer who has the time, resources, and incentive to put your case first.
Looking for a criminal defense attorney in Jefferson City or Mid-Missouri? At Ernst Law LLC, we provide aggressive, personalized defense for clients facing charges ranging from DWI and drug crimes to assault and serious felonies. Contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation.